Home / Markets / Milwaukee, WI / Neighborhoods

Best Neighborhoods in Milwaukee, WI for Rental Property Investors

City Median Price

$200,000

City Median Rent

$1,100/mo

City DSCR (75% LTV)

0.81

Neighborhoods

6

Milwaukee is an underrated Midwest market with affordable housing, a strong manufacturing and healthcare economy, and a growing downtown scene. The city offers excellent cash flow opportunities with some of the highest rent-to-price ratios among major metros. Duplexes and small multifamily are abundant.

Bay View

ZIP: 53207
Grade A

Bay View is Milwaukee trendiest neighborhood with Kinnickinnic Avenue restaurants, lakefront access, and a creative community. Properties have appreciated strongly and attract young professionals. Duplexes here are particularly popular with house-hackers and investors.

Price: $200K-$310KRent: $1,200-$1,600Strategy: Buy and Hold

Riverwest

ZIP: 53212
Grade B

Riverwest is an eclectic neighborhood with a cooperative community identity, affordable duplexes, and proximity to UW-Milwaukee. Rental demand from students and young professionals keeps vacancy low. Properties offer strong cash flow at moderate price points.

Price: $130K-$210KRent: $950-$1,300Strategy: Buy and Hold

Sherman Park

ZIP: 53210
Grade C

Sherman Park has beautiful old housing stock with large duplexes available at deep discounts. The neighborhood has an active community association working on revitalization. Investors can achieve exceptional cash flow but should budget for deferred maintenance on older properties.

Price: $80K-$140KRent: $800-$1,050Strategy: BRRRR

Wauwatosa

ZIP: 53213
Grade A

Wauwatosa is an established western suburb with the Mayfair Mall area, excellent schools, and a charming village downtown. Properties attract families and professionals from the nearby Medical College of Wisconsin and major hospital campus.

Price: $260K-$380KRent: $1,400-$1,800Strategy: Buy and Hold

Walker Point

ZIP: 53204
Grade B

Walker Point south of downtown has transformed with new restaurants, galleries, and the Iron Horse Hotel anchoring revitalization. Properties are appreciating as the neighborhood attracts creative professionals. Small multifamily buildings offer good value.

Price: $160K-$260KRent: $1,100-$1,450Strategy: Value-Add

Washington Heights

ZIP: 53208
Grade C

Washington Heights on the near west side has large brick duplexes and four-unit buildings available at affordable prices. The housing stock has character but often needs updating. Investors focused on multi-unit cash flow will find compelling opportunities.

Price: $100K-$170KRent: $850-$1,100Strategy: BRRRR

Found a Milwaukee neighborhood you like?

See the exact DSCR rate for your scenario. Hundreds of lenders compared instantly.